Old Edwards Reserve and The Cliffs are the two private-club options at the top of the Lake Keowee market. Both are gated, both anchor the luxury tier, and both attract the same broad national buyer pool. But the communities are structurally different — and the wrong fit shows up quickly.
This page is the head-to-head.
Side by Side
The structural differences that decide the answer.
Hospitality Standard
Imported from Old Edwards Inn (Highlands, NC) — Forbes Five-Star benchmark. Smaller-scale, higher-touch operations. Member service profile feels closer to a refined hotel than a country club.
Community Scale
Intentionally smaller — fewer total homesites, more selective membership process, more curated architectural environment via a stricter ARB.
Reciprocity
Old Edwards Club at Highlands Cove (NC) — single reciprocal partner. The Old Edwards brand relationship extends to Inn benefits where applicable.
Amenity Density
Three Lake Keowee Cliffs communities (Falls, Springs, Vineyards) plus four NC mountain communities. Multiple courses, multiple clubhouses, marinas, equestrian, beach club, wellness — the deepest amenity stack on the lake.
Community Scale
Larger communities. More residents, more inventory turnover, more active member calendars, deeper resale liquidity.
Reciprocity
Seven clubs across the Carolinas — three on Lake Keowee, four in the NC mountains (Walnut Cove, Glassy, Mountain Park, Valley). Members rotate freely. The structural advantage that makes a Cliffs membership uniquely valuable for dual-residency buyers.
How to Decide
A buyer-side framework for picking the right answer.
Reserve is the answer if
...you specifically want the Old Edwards hospitality standard, a smaller and more selective community, the most curated architectural environment, and a higher-touch member experience. The smaller community trades off resale liquidity but rewards owners who plan to hold long-term. Reserve guide →
The Cliffs is the answer if
...you value seven-club reciprocity (especially if you maintain or anticipate a second mountain home), the deepest amenity stack on Lake Keowee, deeper resale liquidity, and a more active community calendar. Cliffs guide →
Both at once is reasonable
A meaningful share of buyers consider both communities and tour each before deciding. They are different products at similar price points. Touring both — even briefly — is almost always the right diligence.
Have a Lake Keowee question?
A 30-minute conversation is the fastest way to get a confident next step.